Both ladies rocked this monochrome Valentino gown but which one wore it better?
Jennifer Aniston wore the dress in November last year but she played it down with loose slightly tousled hair and a simple white clutch.
Maria Carey wore it at the American Idol Premiere last week but cut a different figure with an ample bust and plenty of sparkle.
Which star do you think carries off this gown better?
Do you like the Valentino design?
